Evidence and sources

Burning when she passes urine. What is worth finding out?

Preview, not yet reviewedNumbers are teaching estimates awaiting clinician review. Not clinical evidence.Back to the caseOpen in the studio

This page contains the answers. It is best read after you have played the case.

How the verdicts are worked out

The case is a small, complete world: 4 possible causes, 7 things you can ask, examine, test or send, and 5 calls. Each number below says how likely a cause is at the start, how often each finding appears with each cause, and what each call is worth if a given cause is true.

Where a number is uncertain it carries a range. The engine works out every point the consultation can reach, exactly, at both ends of each range (2 versions of the case), and builds one reference plan that is best on average across them. Every option is then scored as "do this, then follow that same plan" in each version, so every comparison is between things a real clinician could actually do.

Sound: nothing materially better was available in any version. Depends: the best choice in some versions, not others. Also sound: no single alternative is materially better in every version. Criticised: one alternative, which the working names, is materially better in every version. "Materially" means by more than 1/200 on the scale where 1 is the best call if you knew the cause; each minute of the 10-minute consultation costs 1/1000 on that scale.

A separate checker that shares no code with the engine re-derives every value and every verdict before the site is built. You can run it yourself: see the end of this page.

Sources

Numbers marked "estimated for teaching" are the case author's judgements, set so the case reproduces the guidance above; they are shown so you can disagree with them.

Every number

How likely each cause is at the start

Starting likelihood of each cause
CauseLikelihood
cystitis50% to 65%
not a bacterial infection20% to 35% (the rest)
vaginal or STI cause12%
pyelonephritis3%

History

Ask about the three key signs (2 min)

How often each result appears with each cause
Resultcystitisnot a bacterial infectionvaginal or STI causepyelonephritis
Two or three key signs75%30%25%80%
One or none25%70%75%20%

Ask about discharge or itch (1 min)

How often each result appears with each cause
Resultcystitisnot a bacterial infectionvaginal or STI causepyelonephritis
Discharge or itch5%8%75%5%
Neither95%92%25%95%

Ask about upper-tract symptoms (1 min)

How often each result appears with each cause
Resultcystitisnot a bacterial infectionvaginal or STI causepyelonephritis
Upper-tract symptoms4%2%2%85%
None96%98%98%15%

Examination

Take a temperature (1 min)

How often each result appears with each cause
Resultcystitisnot a bacterial infectionvaginal or STI causepyelonephritis
38 or more5%3%3%70%
Normal95%97%97%30%
  • Estimated for teaching by the case author, awaiting clinician review

Examine for renal angle tenderness (1 min)

How often each result appears with each cause
Resultcystitisnot a bacterial infectionvaginal or STI causepyelonephritis
Tender8%5%3%75%
Not tender92%95%97%25%
  • Estimated for teaching by the case author, awaiting clinician review

Near-patient tests

Dipstick the urine (3 min)

How often each result appears with each cause
Resultcystitisnot a bacterial infectionvaginal or STI causepyelonephritis
Nitrite positive45%8%6%60%
Leucocytes and blood only30%25%40%30%
Neither pattern25%67%54%10%

Send away

Send a urine culture (1 min, result after the consultation)

The result arrives after the consultation, so nothing it shows can change the call made today. It costs its minutes and a small burden.

  • Estimated for teaching by the case author, awaiting clinician review: Cost of a test or a sample on the utility scale, beyond its minutes.

What each call is worth, if a given cause is true

Value of each call on a scale where 1 is the best call if you knew the cause
Callcystitisnot a bacterial infectionvaginal or STI causepyelonephritis
No antibiotic: consider other causes, self-care and a clear net0.551.000.500.00
Back-up prescription, to start if no better in 48 hours or worse sooner0.930.870.450.10
Antibiotic now (nitrofurantoin, three days)1.000.600.400.30
Swabs and sexual health assessment0.500.851.000.05
Treat as an upper urinary tract infection, with same-day review0.800.450.301.00

Check the working yourself

Download this case's file and the public checker (Python, standard library only), then run:

python3 verify_rich.py dysuria_rich.json

It recomputes every value, reference choice and verdict from the numbers above and reports "verified" or the first thing that does not match. Case file fingerprint: bfd8dedaabbb36fa13135d0dfbe7b3b0797b18e86d815198235499b4257d62e5