Preview · awaiting clinical review
Burning when she passes urine. What is worth finding out?
Priya, 34
Priya has had burning when she passes urine for two days. She is not pregnant and asks whether she needs antibiotics.
A decision exercise with a ten-minute clock. You choose what to ask, examine, test or send; not everything is worth its minutes, and a culture only reports after the consultation. Pregnancy, immunosuppression and catheters have been excluded before the exercise starts.
Probability of a bacterial urinary infection, before you know anything else.
The consultation
Choose what to ask, examine, test or send. Each option costs minutes. Some results arrive only after the consultation. Make the call when you have enough.
Your call
Probability of a bacterial urinary infection, using only what you found out.
Your working
One thing to take away
Your worry
Your route
The checked route from the same start
Day three: the results come back
Back in clinical practice
For non-pregnant women under 65, two or three of dysuria, new nocturia and cloudy urine make a UTI likely and a dipstick adds little; with one or none, a dipstick helps. Vaginal discharge or itch points to other diagnoses. Fever, loin pain, rigors or vomiting suggest an upper urinary tract infection, which needs different antibiotics and same-day review. This simplified model cannot decide a real prescription.
Safety net. Advise self-care and when to return: fever, loin pain, vomiting, feeling very unwell, no improvement within 48 hours of antibiotics, or worsening at any point. Send a culture if symptoms recur or do not respond.
Sources and further reading
- UKHSA: diagnosis of urinary tract infections in primary care. Key signs (dysuria, new nocturia, cloudy urine), when a dipstick helps, other diagnoses to consider with vaginal discharge, and features of upper urinary tract infection.
- Little et al., HTA 2009: dipsticks and diagnostic algorithms. Order of magnitude of the starting likelihood and the pattern of dipstick accuracy.
- NICE NG109: urinary tract infection (lower), antimicrobial prescribing. The guidance this case follows. Management of lower urinary tract infection: immediate or back-up antibiotics, self-care and safety netting.
- NICE NG111: pyelonephritis (acute), antimicrobial prescribing. Recognition and management of upper urinary tract infection.
Every number in this case, and where it came fromHow the verdicts are worked out
What the verdicts mean
Sound: nothing materially better was available, whichever starting likelihood is true. Depends: the best choice for some starting likelihoods, not others. Also sound: no single alternative is materially better in every case. Criticised: one alternative, named, is materially better whatever the starting likelihood. Differences smaller than the case's materiality threshold are never criticised.